Below is Op-Ed text (presumably awaiting moderation) I posted this morning in response to the article posted by Fortune Magazine following the release of the ‘Salmon Fraud’ report this week: “Your salmon may not be as ‘wild’ as you think” (29.10.2015) which concludes: “[…] But they [Oceana] were able to prove that this fraud is occurring, and there isn’t really much we can do about it short of DNA-testing every piece of fish we buy.”
Below is the latest PR from the Antarctic Ocean Alliance (AOA), un-edited:
Despite substantial movement from China on Antarctic Conservation,
Southern Ocean progress remains stalled while protection efforts expand around world
HOBART, 30 October 2015 – The Commission for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources (CCAMLR) has again failed to agree to protect key areas in the Ross Sea and in East Antarctica at its annual meeting in Hobart. However, a statement of support by China for a revised Ross Sea Proposal– which has in past years actively blocked this proposal, and a statement of commitment by Russia for inter-sessional discussion of the proposal, has given hope to a process that has thus far been clouded by inaction, uncertainty and active blocking.
The partners of the Antarctic Ocean Alliance (AOA) highlighting CCAMLR’s fifth failure to reach consensus on this issue over a four-year period, called into question its overall ability to deliver on conservation commitments, specifically its capacity to deliver the large-scale network of marine protected areas (MPAs) it had committed to create by 2012.
Two proposals for MPAs in the Ross Sea and East Antarctic coastal region were once again on the table during this week’s meeting, but the required final consensus by CCAMLR’s 24 member nations and the EU was actively blocked. In the case of the Ross Sea, a last-minute expanded proposal negotiated by the proponent countries United States and New Zealand secured China’s support. In the case of East Antarctica, both China and Russia blocked its adoption.
The proposed designations would provide needed long-term protection of many species, including penguins, seals and whales and their critical habitats. In addition, the MPAs would enable scientific research to occur in this near-pristine wilderness, protecting some of the only Southern polar areas left on earth to study marine ecosystems that have remained relatively untouched by human interference.
“China’s endorsement of the expanded Ross Sea proposal is a positive development and we are encouraged that Russia expressed interest in working on this in the coming year. Ultimately, however, the late-breaking nature of the proposal and lack of substantive work early in the meeting resulted in a replay of the previous four meetings, with no consensus reached, no Southern Ocean protections and no relief for the rich ecosystem and millions of animals that call these waters home,” said Andrea Kavanagh, Director of The Pew Charitable Trusts global penguin conservation program.
“What is most disturbing about this year’s failure is the systematic disintegration of CCAMLR’s ability to deliver on its mandate for marine protection. CCAMLR not only struck out again in efforts to create MPAs, but also failed to take necessary measures to improve oversight of fisheries and obtain data critical for effectively managing those fisheries in an era of climate change. At the same time, we are heartened that China is willing to work on protection of the Ross Sea. We hope that China’s new position ensures its future support for the protection of East Antarctica as well, so that in 2016 we see the adoption of both MPA proposals,” said Mark Epstein, Executive Director of the Antarctic and Southern Ocean Coalition (ASOC).
“The continued stalemate at CCAMLR raises questions about the commitments of countries to use every tool at their disposal to build resilience to climate change impacts. Such a disappointing outcome in a year when the international community agreed at the UN – by consensus – to work on a new agreement to protect high seas biodiversity is inexcusable,” added Maritza Schafer, Global Campaign Leader, Oceans, Greenpeace International.
“It is appalling that while the majority of CCAMLR members are more than ready to create significant marine protected areas in Antarctic waters, China and Russia have blocked efforts to negotiate a successful outcome. We commend the efforts of the proponent countries, and others such as Argentina, Chile, Japan, Norway, South Korea, and Ukraine, who spoke out in favor of the MPAs and the promotion of solid Antarctic marine protection in Antarctica, as well as China’s support for the Ross Sea Proposal, and we hope they continue to demand the urgent protection required for Southern Ocean ecosystems,” added Jill Hepp, Project Director of the Antarctic Ocean Alliance.
This year’s CCAMLR meeting began only a few weeks after the hugely successful Our Ocean conference in Chile. In stark contrast to the inaction of the two-week CCAMLR meeting, Our Ocean generated global excitement with the announcement of a number of new, very large MPAs around the world. The new MPAs represent an additional 2,473,000 square kilometres of highly protected marine areas, including huge areas around New Zealand’s Kermadec Islands, and around Chile’s Desventuradas (Unfortunate) and Easter Islands. Earlier this week, Palau’s President established one of the world’s largest protected areas of ocean in the Pacific island nation’s waters.
CCAMLR immediately precedes the 21st Session of the Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP21) taking place in Paris, France in early December 2015. Climate change is already having an impact on the Antarctic environment, particularly in the Antarctic Peninsula region, one of the fastest warming areas on earth.
Marine protected areas can confer significant benefits in the context of climate change and ocean acidification. They can increase species abundance and diversity and therefore ecosystem resilience to climate change and ocean acidification by reducing stress from human activities. They also provide reference areas where the effects of climate change and ocean acidification can be researched and differentiated from the effects of natural variability and human activities.
The Antarctic Ocean Alliance partners will spend the coming year seeking clarification on the points of consideration submitted by blocking countries so that when we attend CCAMLR in 2016 we all delegations prepared to meet CCAMLR’s conservation mandate and make good on commitments for large-scale marine protection. The AOA has identified approximately 40% of the Southern Ocean that warrants lasting protection.
Ross Sea Proposal – The newly revised Ross Sea Marine Protected Area proposal is 20% larger than the previous proposal with a total size of 1.57 million square kilometers. The increase comes from the addition of 322,328 square kilometers of a krill research zone (KRZ) on the western boundary. Only krill fishing that meets the research goals of the marine protected area would be allowed in this area —which also closes off an area that was previously open to toothfish fishing. The joint proposal of the United States and New Zealand to designate a Ross Sea marine protected area has been under consideration since 2011. The Ross Sea, one of the most pristine oceans remaining on Earth, is often referred to as “the Last Ocean.”
East Antarctica Proposal – Likewise, Australia, France and the EU are once proposed the creation of an MPA to protect 946,998 square kilometres of East Antarctic waters that has been under consideration since 2010. This proposal would allow exploratory and research activities within the MPA if they are consistent with its objectives.
The Southern Ocean is home to more than 10,000 unique species including most of the world’s penguins, whales, seabirds, colossal squid and the remarkable Antarctic toothfish – the main target of fishing companies in the region. The Southern Ocean is a crucial area for scientific research, both for studying how intact marine ecosystems function and for determining the impacts of global climate change.
Fully protected marine reserves are areas that are off-limits to fishing and other extractive uses, including fishing. They provide the highest level of protection to all elements of the ocean ecosystem.
Marine protected areas (MPAs) are areas where certain activities are limited or prohibited to meet specific conservation, habitat protection, or fisheries management objectives.
Consensus-based decision-making does not mean that everyone must agree, but that no one should voice disagreement if a measure is to be adopted, which means that one member state can effectively stop a measure from going forward.
The Antarctic Ocean Alliance is a project of the Antarctic and Southern Ocean Coalition and is a coalition of more than 30 leading environmental organisations and high-profile individuals working to achieve large-scale protection for key Antarctic Ocean ecosystems. Alliance members include The Pew Charitable Trusts, Greenpeace, the Antarctic and Southern Ocean Coalition, Humane Society International, Mission Blue (U.S.), Oceans 5 (U.S.), Deep Wave (Germany), the Last Ocean, Forest & Bird (NZ), ECO (NZ), the Korean Federation for Environmental Movement, and Greenovation Hub (China). Associate partners include the Natural Resources Defense Council, Oceana, the International Fund for Animal Welfare, the International Polar Foundation (U.K.), Plant a Fish, CIES-KFEM and the International Programme on the State of the Oceans and OceanCare (Switzerland). AOA ambassadors include actors Leonardo DiCaprio and Edward Norton, oceanographer Dr. Sylvia Earle, entrepreneur Sir Richard Branson, Chinese entrepreneur and explorer Wang Jing, Norwegian explorer Liv Arnesen, and Korean actor Yoo Ji-Tae. More than 1.4 million people around the world have joined the global call for large-scale marine protection in Antarctica over the last five years and thousands have taken action through online petitions, social media and emails to key world leaders to call for protection.
Since its establishment in 1978, the Antarctic and Southern Ocean Coalition has worked full time to preserve the Antarctic continent and the surrounding Southern Ocean. A coalition of over 30 NGOs interested in Antarctic environmental protection, ASOC represents the environmental community at Antarctic governance meetings and works to promote important Antarctic conservation goals. www.asoc.org
Greenpeace is the leading independent campaigning organization that uses peaceful direct action and creative communication to expose global environmental issues. http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/campaigns/oceans/
The Pew Charitable Trusts works globally to establish pragmatic, science-based policies that protect our oceans, conserve our wild lands, and promote the clean energy economy. www.pewtrusts.org
Oceana released a new study on October 28, 2015, that reveals mislabeling of America’s favorite fish – salmon. Oceana collected 82 salmon samples from restaurants and grocery stores and found that 43 percent were mislabeled. DNA testing confirmed that most of the mislabeling (69 percent) consisted of farmed Atlantic salmon being sold as wild-caught product.
Whilst the Oceana findings are factual and – if anything – highlight at worse a fraudulent activity by U.S. restaurants/grocery stores; Oceana is also using this report to stirr the decades-old simplistic and outdated ‘Wild = good vs. Farmed = bad‘ debate (with a pro-USA stance using also the carbon footprint argument)…
Seals are not threatening commercial fishing stocks in Irish waters, with the possible exception of wild Atlantic salmon, according to new research led by Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland, UK. Continue reading “SEALS are not threatening commercial fishing stocks in Irish waters, with the possible exception of wild Atlantic salmon” [“although most salmon eaten on these islands is farmed”] – New research
VANCOUVER B.C. – Salmon farmers in British Columbia are taking further steps towards increasing the availability of information on farming practices and key areas of public interest by publishing a Sustainability Progress Report, released today (October 27, 2015) at GOAL 2015 in Vancouver. Continue reading GOAL 2015: BC Salmon Farmers release their first ever Sustainability Report; “committed to third-party certification” … Antibiotics usage down 7-fold in past decade